MATTHEW 21:23–27, THE AUTHORITY OF JESUS QUESTIONED
RECOGNIZING GOD’S AUTHORITY WITH HUMBLE AND HONEST HEARTS
Introduction
After His triumphant entry into Jerusalem, the cleansing of the Temple, and the cursing of the fig tree, Jesus continues to teach openly in the Temple area. His words and actions have already exposed the corruption, hypocrisy, and spiritual barrenness of the religious leadership. At this critical moment, the chief priests and elders confront Jesus, not to seek truth, but to protect their own power. Their question about authority is not sincere; it is strategic. Jesus responds with divine wisdom, revealing that the real issue is not His authority, but their unwillingness to recognize God’s work when it challenges their pride. This passage invites every believer to examine whether we truly submit to God’s authority or merely defend our own.
Bible Passage (Matthew 21:23–27)
When he had come into the temple area, the chief priests and the elders of the people approached him as he was teaching and said, “By what authority are you doing these things? And who gave you this authority?” Jesus said to them in reply, “I shall ask you one question, and if you answer it for me, then I shall tell you by what authority I do these things. Where was John’s baptism from? Was it of heavenly or of human origin?” They discussed this among themselves and said, “If we say, ‘Of heavenly origin,’ he will say to us, ‘Then why did you not believe him?’ But if we say, ‘Of human origin,’ we fear the crowd, for they all regard John as a prophet.” So they said to Jesus in reply, “We do not know.” He himself said to them, “Neither shall I tell you by what authority I do these things.”
Background
This confrontation takes place in the Temple, the heart of Jewish religious life and the center of authority for the chief priests and elders. Jesus has just challenged their control by cleansing the Temple and teaching with clarity and power. In Jewish tradition, rabbis taught under the authority of recognized teachers or institutions. Jesus, however, teaches with divine authority, independent of human endorsement. The leaders demand credentials because Jesus threatens their religious monopoly. By bringing John the Baptist into the discussion, Jesus exposes their spiritual inconsistency and fear of public opinion.
Opening Life Connection
Even today, people often question authority not to understand, but to resist change. Parents, teachers, pastors, and Church leaders sometimes face challenges not because they are wrong, but because their words unsettle comfortable habits. In our personal lives, we may question God’s authority when His Word confronts our lifestyle, priorities, or hidden sins. This Gospel asks us: Do we truly want God’s truth, or only what supports our preferences?
Verse-by-Verse / Phrase-by-Phrase Reflection
“The chief priests and the elders… approached him as he was teaching”
These were the highest religious authorities. Their approach appears official, but their hearts are defensive. They confront Jesus while He is teaching, showing their discomfort with His influence over the people.
“By what authority are you doing these things?”
They refer especially to His cleansing of the Temple and His authoritative teaching. The question is less about theology and more about control.
“Who gave you this authority?”
They expect Jesus to cite a human institution. Their mindset cannot accept divine authority operating outside their system.
“I shall ask you one question”
Jesus does not evade the issue; He reframes it. Divine wisdom exposes hidden motives by asking the right question.
“Where was John’s baptism from?”
John’s ministry prepared the way for Jesus. Accepting John means accepting Jesus. Rejecting John exposes resistance to God.
“They discussed this among themselves”
Instead of seeking truth, they calculate consequences. Their concern is not God’s will, but political safety and reputation.
“We fear the crowd”
Fear of people replaces fear of God. Authority rooted in popularity collapses when truth demands courage.
“We do not know”
This is not ignorance; it is evasion. They choose dishonesty over conversion.
“Neither shall I tell you by what authority I do these things”
Jesus respects freedom. Those unwilling to acknowledge God’s work are not ready to receive deeper truth.
Jewish Historical and Religious Context
In first-century Judaism, authority came through lineage, rabbinic training, or Temple office. John the Baptist operated outside the Temple system, yet the people recognized him as a prophet. Jesus follows the same prophetic pattern. The leaders’ refusal to acknowledge John reveals their rejection of prophetic authority when it threatens institutional power. This confrontation echoes Old Testament prophets who were rejected by religious elites despite being sent by God.
Catholic Tradition and Teaching
The Church teaches that Christ’s authority comes from the Father and is exercised in truth, service, and love. Legitimate authority in the Church participates in Christ’s authority when it serves God’s people faithfully. This passage warns against clericalism, hypocrisy, and fear-driven leadership. It also reminds the faithful that obedience to God sometimes requires courage to accept uncomfortable truths.
Historical or Saintly Illustration
Saint John Chrysostom boldly preached against corruption and injustice among the powerful, both civil and religious. When challenged for his authority, he did not rely on human approval but on fidelity to the Gospel. Like John the Baptist and Jesus, he faced opposition because truth unsettles those invested in power.
Application to Christian Life Today
This Gospel calls us to honesty before God. When God speaks through Scripture, Church teaching, conscience, or authentic witnesses, do we listen—or do we calculate what suits us best? It challenges leaders to exercise authority as service, not control. It challenges believers to accept God’s authority even when it calls for repentance, humility, and change.
Eucharistic Connection
At every Eucharist, Christ teaches and acts with divine authority. He cleanses hearts, nourishes faith, and calls for conversion. Approaching the altar demands honesty: we cannot receive the Lord while resisting His authority over our lives. The Eucharist strengthens us to choose truth over fear and obedience over convenience.
Messages / Call to Conversion
-
Examine whether you question God’s authority out of sincerity or resistance.
-
Ask for the grace to recognize God’s work even when it challenges comfort or pride.
-
Choose fear of God over fear of people.
-
Practice honesty in faith rather than evasive neutrality.
-
Submit daily decisions to Christ’s authority with trust and humility.
Outline for Preachers
• Context: Temple teaching after cleansing
• Life connection: questioning authority to resist change
• Key phrases: “By what authority,” “We do not know”
• Role of John the Baptist as prophetic witness
• Fear of people versus fear of God
• Catholic understanding of Christ’s authority
• Saintly example of courageous truth
• Application to personal and communal faith
• Eucharistic call to honest obedience
• Key messages and call to conversion
