MARK 15:6–15, THE SENTENCE OF DEATH
THE INNOCENT CONDEMNED AND THE GUILTY SET FREE
Introduction
The Passion now reaches a decisive and tragic turning point. Jesus stands before the crowd, not hidden in darkness, but exposed in public judgment. What precedes this moment is silence before Pilate; what follows will be mockery, scourging, and the way of the cross. Here the fate of Jesus is placed before the people, and the drama of human choice unfolds. The scene forces us to confront a painful truth: salvation advances not only through what God does, but through what humanity chooses—and often chooses wrongly.
Bible Passage (Mark 15:6–15)
Now on the occasion of the feast he used to release to them one prisoner whom they requested. A man called Barabbas was then in prison along with the rebels who had committed murder in a rebellion. The crowd came forward and began to ask him to do for them as he was accustomed. Pilate answered, “Do you want me to release to you the king of the Jews?” For he knew that it was out of envy that the chief priests had handed him over. But the chief priests stirred up the crowd to have him release Barabbas for them instead. Pilate again said to them in reply, “Then what do you want me to do with the man you call the king of the Jews?” They shouted again, “Crucify him.” Pilate said to them, “Why? What evil has he done?” They only shouted the louder, “Crucify him.” So Pilate, wishing to satisfy the crowd, released Barabbas to them and, after he had Jesus scourged, handed him over to be crucified.
Background
This passage belongs to the Roman phase of Jesus’ trial. The custom of releasing a prisoner at Passover was meant to placate the people during a volatile feast celebrating freedom. Mark highlights the irony: at the feast of liberation, the truly innocent one is condemned, and a violent rebel is set free. The Old Testament pattern of the scapegoat—where guilt is transferred and innocence suffers—quietly echoes in this exchange, preparing us to see Jesus as the one who bears the sins of many.
Opening Life Connection
In many areas of life, people choose what feels immediately satisfying rather than what is right. Popular opinion, emotional pressure, and fear of unrest often override conscience. This Gospel speaks to moments when truth stands before us, but we are tempted to choose the easier, louder, or more self-serving option.
Verse-by-Verse / Phrase-by-Phrase Reflection
Mark notes the custom: “on the occasion of the feast he used to release to them one prisoner”. What was meant as an act of mercy becomes a stage for injustice. The prisoner presented is “Barabbas”, described as one who “had committed murder in a rebellion”. He represents violent resistance and destructive power—the kind of “savior” people sometimes prefer when fear dominates.
The crowd “came forward and began to ask”, initiating the choice. Pilate offers Jesus with calculated hope: “do you want me to release to you the king of the Jews?” Mark reveals Pilate’s awareness: “he knew that it was out of envy” that Jesus was handed over. Knowledge, however, does not lead to courage.
The turning point comes when “the chief priests stirred up the crowd”. Manipulated voices drown out conscience. The people are no longer discerning; they are driven. When Pilate asks again, “what do you want me to do with the man you call the king of the Jews?”, responsibility is placed squarely before them.
Their response is chillingly simple: “crucify him”. The word is repeated, growing louder, revealing how violence gains momentum when unchecked. Pilate asks the haunting question, “what evil has he done?”—a question left unanswered. Truth receives no defense; it is simply shouted down.
Finally, “wishing to satisfy the crowd”, Pilate chooses popularity over justice. “He released Barabbas”—the guilty walks free—while “after he had Jesus scourged, handed him over”. Suffering is inflicted before death, showing how injustice multiplies once truth is abandoned. The sentence of death is passed, not because Jesus is guilty, but because fear prevails.
Jewish Historical and Religious Context
Passover celebrated God’s deliverance from oppression. Releasing a prisoner symbolized mercy and freedom. Barabbas, a rebel, embodied political violence, while Jesus embodied sacrificial love. The crowd’s choice reveals a misunderstanding of salvation—expecting liberation through force rather than through obedience and love.
Catholic Tradition and Teaching
The Church teaches that Christ’s condemnation reveals the depth of human sin and the greater depth of divine mercy. Jesus takes the place of the guilty so that the guilty may go free. This exchange lies at the heart of redemption: the innocent suffers so that sinners may live. Pilate’s failure warns against moral compromise, while Christ’s surrender reveals saving love.
Historical or Saintly Illustration
Saint Edith Stein reflected on this scene while contemplating human responsibility for injustice. She taught that neutrality in the face of evil is itself a choice. Like Pilate, those who know the truth but fail to act contribute to suffering. Her witness urges courage rooted in faith.
Application to Christian Life Today
This Gospel challenges believers to examine daily choices. Whom do we choose—Christ or comfort, truth or approval? In families, workplaces, and society, disciples are called to resist manipulation and stand for what is right, even when it costs. Silence and passivity can become participation in injustice.
Eucharistic Connection
The one handed over to be crucified is the same one who gives himself as food. Every Eucharist proclaims this exchange: Christ takes our place so that we may receive life. Receiving his Body and Blood commits believers to choose him daily, rejecting the false “Barabbases” that promise freedom but deliver violence.
Messages / Call to Conversion
-
Humanity’s sin condemns the innocent and frees the guilty.
-
Repent of choosing comfort, popularity, or fear over truth.
-
Recognize Christ as the true liberator, not false saviors.
-
Trust that God brings salvation even through human injustice.
-
Resolve to choose Christ courageously in every moral decision.
Outline for Preachers
-
Passover custom and public judgment
-
Contrast between Jesus and Barabbas
-
Crowd manipulation and Pilate’s weakness
-
Repeated cry of “crucify him” and silenced truth
-
Jewish understanding of liberation and mercy
-
Catholic teaching on substitution and redemption
-
Saintly reflection on responsibility and conscience
-
Application to modern moral choices and social pressure
-
Eucharistic meaning of Christ taking our place
-
Call to conversion: courage, truth, and faithful choice
