LUKE 23:18–25, THE SENTENCE OF DEATH
THE INNOCENT CONDEMNED AND THE GUILTY RELEASED
Introduction
This passage brings the Roman trial of Jesus to its tragic conclusion. After repeated declarations of Jesus’ innocence by Pilate, justice collapses under pressure from the crowd. What unfolds is not merely a legal decision, but a dramatic revelation of the human heart when fear, manipulation, and sin prevail over truth. At this moment, Jesus stands as the silent Lamb, while the people choose Barabbas, a man of violence. The sentence of death exposes the cost of discipleship and the mystery of salvation accomplished through injustice freely accepted.
Bible Passage (Luke 23:18–25)
All together the crowd shouted out, “Away with this man! Release Barabbas to us.” Now Barabbas had been imprisoned for a rebellion that had taken place in the city and for murder. Again Pilate addressed them, still wishing to release Jesus, but they continued their shouting, “Crucify him! Crucify him!” Pilate addressed them a third time, “What evil has this man done? I found him guilty of no capital crime. Therefore I shall have him flogged and then release him.” With loud shouts, however, they persisted in calling for his crucifixion, and their voices prevailed. The verdict of Pilate was that their demand should be granted. So Pilate released the man who had been imprisoned for rebellion and murder, for whom they asked, and he handed Jesus over to them to deal with as they wished.
Background
Luke presents this scene as the final stage of Jesus’ trial before Pilate. Three times Pilate declares Jesus innocent, yet three times the crowd demands crucifixion. The custom of releasing a prisoner at the festival sets the stage for a stark contrast between Jesus and Barabbas. The choice made by the people reflects the tragic preference for violence over truth and convenience over conscience. This moment fulfills the pattern of the suffering servant who is rejected despite innocence.
Opening Life Connection
There are moments in society and personal life when truth is known but ignored. Decisions are made not because they are right, but because they are popular, loud, or convenient. Many experience the pain of being treated unjustly while wrongdoing is excused or rewarded. This Gospel speaks to those realities and asks where we stand when truth is costly.
Verse-by-Verse / Phrase-by-Phrase Reflection
The crowd speaks “all together”, showing collective rejection rather than personal discernment. Their cry “away with this man” expresses total dismissal of Jesus’ dignity. They demand “release Barabbas to us”, choosing a man guilty of “rebellion and murder” over the innocent Son of God. Pilate, “still wishing to release Jesus”, attempts compromise, but the crowd intensifies its demand, shouting “crucify him! crucify him!”. The repetition reveals hardened hearts. Pilate’s question, “what evil has this man done?”, is left unanswered, because no crime exists. Though he admits “no capital crime”, he proposes flogging as a concession. Finally, “their voices prevailed”, and justice gives way to noise. Pilate releases the guilty and “handed Jesus over to them”, marking the ultimate exchange: the innocent condemned so the guilty may go free.
Jewish Historical and Religious Context
Crucifixion was a Roman punishment reserved for rebels and slaves. Barabbas fits this category, not Jesus. The crowd’s choice reflects messianic expectations shaped by political violence rather than suffering obedience. The Passover setting intensifies the irony: at the feast of liberation, they choose bondage to sin over true freedom.
Catholic Tradition and Teaching
The Church sees in this exchange the heart of redemption. Christ takes the place of the sinner. Barabbas represents humanity set free at the cost of Christ’s life. The Catechism teaches that Jesus freely accepted death out of love for sinners, fulfilling the Father’s saving plan. The injustice of the sentence becomes the means of salvation.
Historical or Saintly Illustration
Saint Edith Stein, condemned unjustly during the Nazi regime, accepted death in union with Christ for her people. Like Jesus, she bore injustice without hatred, trusting God’s redemptive purpose beyond human courts.
Application to Christian Life Today
This Gospel challenges believers to examine their own choices. Do we choose what is right or what is popular? Do we remain silent when truth is condemned? Christians are called to stand with the innocent, defend truth, and resist the temptation to follow the loudest voice.
Eucharistic Connection
The sentence of death leads directly to the sacrifice made present in the Eucharist. Each Mass proclaims that Christ was handed over so that sinners might be released. Receiving the Eucharist commits believers to live as people set free by costly love.
Messages / Call to Conversion
-
Silence or compromise in the face of injustice leads to grave consequences.
-
Humanity often chooses convenience over truth.
-
Jesus freely takes the place of the guilty.
-
Salvation flows from Christ’s innocent suffering.
-
Disciples are called to stand for truth even when voices oppose it.
Outline for Preachers
-
Final stage of Jesus’ trial before Pilate
-
Human experience of injustice and crowd pressure
-
Key phrases revealing rejection, compromise, and exchange
-
Historical background of Barabbas and crucifixion
-
Catholic teaching on substitution and redemption
-
Saintly witness of innocent suffering
-
Application to moral courage today
-
Eucharistic meaning of Christ handed over
-
Central call to choose truth over convenience
