MATTHEW 17:9–13 – THE ARRIVAL OF ELIJAH
PREPARATION FOR THE MESSIAH AND THE COST OF DISCIPLESHIP
Introduction
After the glory of the Transfiguration, Jesus immediately leads his disciples back into the path of obedience and suffering. Only Peter, James, and John witnessed this revelation, and Jesus commanded them to keep silence until after his resurrection. The appearance of Elijah raises an important question rooted in Jewish expectation: if Elijah must come before the Messiah, how is this prophecy fulfilled? Jesus explains that Elijah has already come in an unexpected way, through John the Baptist. His rejection and death foreshadow the suffering that awaits the Son of Man. This passage teaches that God’s promises are fulfilled through humility, repentance, and sacrifice, not through spectacle or power.
Bible Passage (Matthew 17:9–13)
As they were coming down the mountain, Jesus commanded them not to tell anyone of the vision until the Son of Man had been raised from the dead. Then the disciples asked him, “Why do the teachers of the Law say that Elijah must come first?” He said in reply, “Elijah will indeed come and restore all things; but I tell you that Elijah has already come, and they did not recognize him but did to him whatever they pleased. So also will the Son of Man suffer at their hands.” Then the disciples understood that he was speaking to them of John the Baptist.
Background
This passage follows Peter’s confession of faith, Jesus’ first prediction of the Passion, and the Transfiguration. The disciples are being formed to understand that glory cannot be separated from the cross. The descent from the mountain symbolizes the return to mission, where faith must be lived in a world that often resists God’s truth.
Opening Life Connection
Many people expect God to act in dramatic or unmistakable ways. When God works through ordinary people, quiet voices, or difficult circumstances, His presence can be overlooked. We too may miss God’s action when it challenges our comfort or calls us to repentance. This Gospel invites us to recognize God’s work even when it comes through suffering.
Verse-by-Verse / Phrase-by-Phrase Reflection
“As they were coming down the mountain”
The movement downward signals a return from spiritual consolation to daily discipleship. Encounters with God are meant to strengthen us for mission, not remove us from reality.
“Do not tell anyone… until the Son of Man has been raised from the dead”
Jesus links revelation to the Resurrection. Without Easter, the Transfiguration could be misunderstood as earthly triumph rather than redemptive glory.
“Why do the teachers of the Law say that Elijah must come first?”
The disciples echo a well-known teaching based on prophecy. Their question shows sincere faith but incomplete understanding.
“Elijah has already come, and they did not recognize him”
Jesus reveals that God’s promises can be fulfilled in hidden ways. John the Baptist fulfilled Elijah’s mission, but many failed to see it.
“They did to him whatever they pleased”
John’s rejection shows how truth is often resisted when it demands conversion. Faithfulness does not guarantee acceptance.
“So also will the Son of Man suffer”
Jesus clearly connects John’s fate with his own Passion. Suffering is not failure, but part of God’s saving plan.
“Then the disciples understood”
Understanding comes gradually. Faith deepens when revelation is interpreted through Jesus’ teaching rather than popular expectation.
Jewish Historical and Religious Context
Elijah was believed to have been taken bodily into heaven and was expected to return visibly before the day of the Lord. John the Baptist did not match this expectation outwardly, yet he fulfilled Elijah’s mission by calling Israel to repentance and preparing hearts for the Messiah.
Catholic Tradition and Teaching
The Church teaches that God’s revelation unfolds according to divine wisdom. John the Baptist is honored as the precursor of Christ, whose mission prepares the way for redemption through the cross and resurrection. Authentic prophecy always leads to conversion and fidelity.
Historical or Saintly Illustration
Many saints were misunderstood or opposed because they challenged complacency and called people back to the Gospel. Like John the Baptist, they prepared the way for Christ through faithful witness, not public approval.
Application to Christian Life Today
Christians are called to discern God’s presence beyond appearances. Fidelity to Christ may involve misunderstanding or suffering, but such faithfulness participates in Christ’s own saving mission and leads to lasting hope.
Eucharistic Connection
In the Eucharist, Christ is truly present under humble signs. Just as Elijah’s return was hidden in John the Baptist, so Jesus comes quietly to strengthen us for the journey from the cross toward resurrection.
Messages / Call to Conversion
-
God fulfills His promises in ways that demand faith and discernment.
-
Rejection does not mean failure when one is faithful to God’s call.
-
True discipleship embraces the cross with hope in resurrection.
-
Learn to recognize God’s action beyond outward expectations.
-
Persevere in faith, trusting that obedience leads to eternal life.
Outline for Preachers
• Context after the Transfiguration and before the Passion
• Jewish expectation of Elijah and its fulfillment in John the Baptist
• God’s work often hidden and misunderstood
• Link between John’s suffering and Jesus’ Passion
• Discipleship as faithfulness amid rejection
• Eucharist as quiet strength for the journey
• Call to perseverance, conversion, and hope
